M

Search The One Ring

‘The War Of The Rohirrim’ Writer Philippa Boyens Defends Changing Tolkien: “Sometimes The Most Compelling Story Is The Untold Story”

Jonathan Watson

December 14, 2024

In a recent promotional interview with IGN, Philippa Boyens, the screenwriter for Peter Jacksons The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit films, reveals that her team decided to tell “the untold story,” that Tolkien never wrote — sound familiar (*ahem* Rings of Power *cough*)?

In the interview, Boyens referenced Tolkien, saying, “Sometimes the most compelling story is the untold story,” referencing a letter he wrote to his son in 1945. By this, she means to justify the film’s departure from what Tolkien wrote canon, as they expand the brief mention of “Helm’s daughter” in the text into a full cinematic experience for the newly named Hera, creating a Mary-sue-girlboss for “modern audiences” in the process.

Similarly, Jason DeMarco, the producer for War of the Rohirrim, echoed Boyens’ sentiments, emphasizing that their goal was to “tell a story within that that didn’t change anything that Tolkien put down, but still fleshed it out.”

But that’s just not true!

Hera from War of the Rohirrim Fighting with a Sword

Hera from War of the Rohirrim

The story of Helm Hammerhand and his defense of the Rohirrim is HIS story — and it’s his nephew Frealaf that makes the bold counterstrike to take back Edoras. Boyens and her screenwriters make Hera the powerful horsemaster-swordmaster-strategist that makes all the right decisions… but her father and brothers just won’t listen to her.

It’s NOT the same story.

Boyens continued in the interview, discussing the narration by Éowyn (voiced by Miranda Otto) which tells audiences not to seek out stories about Héra “in the old songs.” This choice, she argues, is meant to convey to viewers, “We know what we’re doing here. We understand that.” It’s an empty reassurance meant to gloss over the fact that they did indeed change what Tolkien wrote, NOT just tell the “untold story.”

Have you seen the film.  Is Boyens honest in her assessment of telling an “untold story”?  Let us know in the comments below!

Exploring Tolkien app icon
Exploring Tolkien app icon

Get Tolkien News First

The Exploring Tolkien app alerts you the moment news breaks.

QR code: scan with your iPhone camera to get the Exploring Tolkien app
Advertisement

Tolkien Picks

The books and gifts we love most.

The lord of the rings box set.

The Lord of the Rings, One Volume

The hobbit book set with the hobbit logo on the cover.

The Hobbit, Illustrated by Tolkien

The silmarillion audiobook cover art.

The Silmarillion, Read by Andy Serkis

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Jonathan Watson

Jonathan Watson founded TheOneRing.com in April 1999 and has edited it ever since, covering Peter Jackson's films from the first announcement in April 1999 through The Hobbit in 2012, and now The Rings of Power and The Hunt for Gollum. He has interviewed the cast and crew of the films, been interviewed by Wired magazine, and featured on CNN. He co-hosts the Exploring Tolkien podcast with Michael Grumbine, now at nearly 200 episodes, and built the Exploring Tolkien app for iPhone. Jonathan first read The Lord of the Rings in 7th (in ony 1 week) and has been a Tolkien fan every since. In addition to The One Ring, Jonathan runs Creators Web Pro where he builds online homes for creators so they can own their community.

Advertisement

See More of Us on Google

Choose The One Ring as a preferred source and our stories show up first in your Google results.