Alas… The Harfoots are still in The Rings of Power Season 3, though not as much as before. Co-showrunner Patrick McKay told IGN at the show’s press junket that “[We] have not written out the Harfoots,” contradicting earlier reports that the hobbit ancestors were being sidelined. We covered those reports in July, when the show was said to be giving the Harfoots a backseat.
Remember, these are the halflings (or the “Dirty Little Sociopaths” as Michael Grumbine, our co-host on Exploring Tolkien podcast has named them) that chant that no hobbit should go “off trail” and nobody “walks alone”. Until we find out that if a hobbit DOES go off trail they’ll happily leave them behind to die a lonely death.
McKay said Season 3 was built to be darker and more focused. “It’s the season where Sauron forges the One Ring, and we wanted that to unify every single storyline,” he said. “We didn’t want it to have sprawl the way we enjoyed having in the past.” If a story was not about the rings, Sauron or the One Ring, putting it in “would feel forced.” Still, “you can’t count a halfling out, the Harfoots and Markella and Megan’s characters. They’ll be back maybe sooner than you think.” The reference is to Markella Kavenagh and Megan Richardson, who play Nori Brandyfoot and Poppy Proudfellow.
I think leaving your fellow citizens to die alone if they get stuck in a snow drift or have a gimpy leg is pretty dark, actually.
It remains to be seen how many scenes the Harfoots get. At the end of Season 2, Nori and Poppy said goodbye to the Stranger (Daniel Weyman) and left with the Stoors to look for a new home after the Dark Wizard destroyed their canyon. The Stoors called the Stranger “Grand Elf,” which is where the show gets the name Gandalf (insert eye roll).
In Tolkien, hobbits do not appear in the Second Age. Appendix B of The Lord of the Rings has them first noted in the records around the year 1050 of the Third Age, when the Harfoots move into Eriador, with the Fallohides and Stoors following around 1150.
The first four episodes premiere November 11. Episodes 5 and 6 follow on November 18, and the last two on November 25.
Find more Tolkien talk on our Exploring Tolkien YouTube channel.
