M

Search The One Ring

Rings of Power Changes › Character

Theo

How The Rings of Power's Theo, the Southlands boy who finds a broken sword hilt, compares with what Tolkien wrote about the Men of the south, Mordor, and Pelargir.

How Close to Tolkien?

Theo is a character invented for The Rings of Power. He is the teenage son of Bronwyn, a healer of Tirharad in the Southlands, and his father is gone. In Season 1 he finds a broken sword hilt in a neighbour's barn and hides it. Adar wants the hilt, and in episode 6 Theo gives up its hiding place to stop the killing of the villagers. Adar uses it to flood the tunnels under the mountain, which erupts, and the Southlands become Mordor. In Season 2 Theo lives in Pelargir after his mother's death, is held for a time by the Ents, and at the end faces Kemen, Pharazôn's son, who makes the town a fortress for Númenor's fleet. Tolkien wrote no Theo, no hilt, and no Southlands villages. In his account Sauron chose Mordor for himself around S.A. 1000 because of the fire of Orodruin, and Pelargir was built in S.A. 2350 as the haven of the Númenóreans who stayed loyal to the Valar. The show does keep Tolkien's picture of Númenor taking timber and tribute from the lands it once helped.

Exploring Tolkien app icon
Exploring Tolkien app icon

Explore Tolkien. Every Day.

Read-throughs of Tolkien's books, deep conversations, videos, live chat, member-exclusives, and more.

QR code: scan with your iPhone camera to get the Exploring Tolkien app

Theo in the Show and in Tolkien

Is Theo in Tolkien's books?

Changed

The Rings of Power

Theo is a boy of Tirharad, a village of Men in the Southlands watched by an Elvish garrison. Other boys taunt him about his father, who left, and Arondir says in Season 1, episode 5, that Theo is 14. Theo resents the Elves for watching his people all his life. He goes with the villagers to the old watchtower when Orcs attack, and after the disaster of episode 6 he travels with Galadriel to the Númenórean camp, where he finds his mother alive. In Season 2, episode 3, Bronwyn has died and Theo lives with the survivors in Pelargir. He asks Arondir whether he knew his father, learns that he did not, and tells Arondir they are done. That night he goes alone to a Wildmen camp, claims to serve Adar, and is taken. In episode 4 Arondir finds that Ents hold the prisoners, and Theo is set free. In episode 8 Kemen meets Theo as Bronwyn's son and is told that he leads half the colony.
A boy with shaggy dark hair lit by a warm fire speaks to someone in the foreground

Tolkien

Tolkien wrote no Theo, no Bronwyn, and no village of Tirharad. His Men of the south appear only as peoples, never as named families. The Silmarillion says that early in the Second Age Men multiplied in the south and the far east, and most of them turned to evil because Sauron was at work among them. Later nearly all Men of the east and south were under his rule, built towns and walls of stone, and took him as both king and god.

The Silmarillion, "Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age"

Verdict. Tolkien's Men of the south go over to Sauron while he is among them, by their own choice and through his lies. Theo's story turns that history into a coming-of-age tale about a boy, a dead mother, and a missing father, and his people are tempted by a relic left over from an earlier age while Sauron is somewhere else. The show gives a southern Man a sympathetic face, which Tolkien rarely does, but nothing in Theo's arc comes from Tolkien's account of how the south fell.

Did a sword hilt turn the Southlands into Mordor?

Changed

The Rings of Power

In Season 1, episode 1, Theo shows a friend a broken hilt he found under a loose board in Waldreg's barn and keeps it hidden. In episode 4 Orcs searching Tirharad catch sight of a boy carrying it. Waldreg, who knows Theo took it, tells him the hilt holds a power, made for their forefathers by the hand of Sauron's master, and asks if he has heard of Sauron. In episode 5 Arondir says the hilt is a key, made by the enemy to enslave Theo's ancestors, and that Adar needs it. In episode 6 Adar holds the villagers and starts to kill them, and Theo shows where the hilt is hidden. Adar sends Waldreg with it to open a dam, the water floods the tunnels under the mountain, and the mountain erupts. In episode 7 Theo tells Galadriel the ruin is his fault, and she urges him not to carry it.
Inside a barn lit through slatted walls, a young man in a fur coat stands over a boy lying in the straw

Tolkien

Tolkien has no hilt, no key, and no flooding of the mountain. The Tale of Years says that around S.A. 1000 Sauron, alarmed by the growing power of Númenor, chose Mordor as a land to make into a stronghold and began to build Barad-dûr. The Silmarillion explains why: Sauron had set his dwelling there long before because of Orodruin, the fiery mountain, whose fire he used in his sorceries and his forging. By the days of Tar-Minastir he had fortified Mordor, and around S.A. 1600 he forged the One Ring there. Tolkien never says that Orodruin was made by an eruption in the Second Age, or that Mordor had been a green land of Men.

The Lord of the Rings, Appendix B, "The Second Age"; The Silmarillion, "Akallabêth" and "Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age"

Verdict. In Tolkien, Mordor is Sauron's own choice and his own work, picked for a fire that was already burning, and he makes it his seat centuries before the Rings. In the show the land is made by Adar's plan for his Orcs, with Sauron absent and a boy's hidden find at the centre of it. Morgoth making a sword as a key for Men of the south is the show's own idea, and it leaves the Dark Lord's realm as the result of a plot he had no part in.

Was Pelargir an old Númenórean colony in Míriel's time?

Changed

The Rings of Power

In Season 1, episode 7, Bronwyn plans to lead the survivors to Pelargir, which she calls an old Númenórean colony by the mouth of the Anduin. In Season 2 Theo lives there among the refugees, and in episode 4 Arondir, leaving, calls him the Lord of Pelargir. In episode 8 Kemen, Pharazôn's son, arrives by ship and announces that Pelargir is now a fortress for Númenor's soldiers, with Kemen as its commander. Any Man who stays must supply timber for the King's fleet.
On a lakeside jetty, a boy in a padded tunic stands among soldiers and villagers behind a smiling man in green

Tolkien

The Tale of Years says Pelargir was built in S.A. 2350 and became the chief haven of the Faithful, the Númenóreans who kept faith with the Elves and the Valar. The Akallabêth says the Elf-friends came to Middle-earth to aid Gil-galad against Sauron and that their haven was Pelargir, above the mouths of the Anduin. The King's Men, who turned against the Valar, sailed far to the south and made their own lordships there. Umbar was made a great fortress in S.A. 2280, and it was at Umbar that Ar-Pharazôn landed when he came to humble Sauron.

The Lord of the Rings, Appendix B, "The Second Age"; The Silmarillion, "Akallabêth"; Unfinished Tales, "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", Appendix D

Verdict. Tolkien keeps the Faithful and the King's Men apart in Middle-earth as well as in Númenor: Pelargir is the haven of the loyal few, and Umbar is the King's. In the show Pelargir is an old colony where refugees from the Southlands settle, until the son of Pharazôn takes it as a base for his armada. Tolkien's Pelargir had been the haven of the Faithful for about nine centuries when Pharazôn took the sceptre, and the show gives it to the side Tolkien set against it.

Did Númenor strip the forests of Middle-earth for its ships?

Unchanged

The Rings of Power

Yes. In Season 2, episode 8, Kemen orders the Men of Pelargir to deliver a regular supply of timber from the forests around the town for the building of his father's armada, and he holds back the food for the winter that Númenor had promised them.
A dark-haired boy in a padded tunic speaks, a long-haired man and soldiers in green behind him

Tolkien

Unfinished Tales tells how Tar-Aldarion, the Mariner-king, wanted timber to make Númenor a great sea power and founded a haven at the mouth of the Gwathlo. For long years the forests of Minhiriath and Enedwaith were Númenor's chief source of timber, and shiploads went west over the sea. The damage was beyond counting, and the native Men who were driven out welcomed Sauron and hoped he would defeat the Men of the Sea. The Akallabêth adds that the Númenóreans came to the coasts as lords who gathered tribute, where once they had come as helpers and teachers. Tolkien places this felling in Eriador, centuries before Pharazôn.

Unfinished Tales, "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", Appendix D; The Silmarillion, "Akallabêth"

Common Questions

Is Theo in The Lord of the Rings or The Silmarillion?

No. Theo was created for The Rings of Power. Tolkien wrote no character of that name, and no village of Men in the land that became Mordor.

Who plays Theo in The Rings of Power?

Tyroe Muhafidin plays Theo in Seasons 1 and 2.

What is Theo's sword in The Rings of Power?

It is a broken hilt that Waldreg says was made for the forefathers of the Southlands Men by Sauron's master, and that Arondir calls a key. Adar uses it to flood the tunnels under the mountain, which erupts and turns the Southlands into Mordor. Tolkien has no such hilt. In his account Sauron chose Mordor around S.A. 1000 for the fire of Orodruin.

Who is Theo's father?

The show does not say. In Season 2, episode 3, Theo asks Arondir whether he knew his father, and Arondir says he did not.

What happens to Theo in Season 2?

After his mother Bronwyn dies, Theo lives in Pelargir. He is captured near a Wildmen camp, held by the Ents with other prisoners, and freed after Arondir speaks for them. In the last episode Kemen arrives and makes Pelargir a fortress for Númenor's fleet.