Face-Off! The Hobbit : An Unexpected Journey vs. The Fellowship of the Ring

AncalagonTheBlack studying as usual, of course...AncalagonTheBlack studying as usual, of course...Our resident archivist and analyst extraordinaire Ancalagon the Black (famous, of course, for The Complete List of Film Changes), has noted some distinct similarities between The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, and The Fellowship of the Ring.

He's noted that the first third of Tolkien's Hobbit novel has very similar story beats to The Fellowship of the Ring, and with Peter Jackson's additions, the films are even more alike.

We're asking you to tell us which film does better in each of these sequences... then comment below, or head over to Ancalagon's thread on our messageboard to tell us why you chose what you chose!

One quick note:
AUJ = The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
FOTR = The Fellowship of the Ring

Add New Comment

Latest Forum Posts

Join the Conversation!