Jottler

Sam at Cirith Ungol (The Spider's Pass)

   (Add a Comment and Rate This)

Hildebrandt

Rating: 4.42      Total Ratings: 40


 

Reader Comments

   (Add a Comment and Rate This)

... 46 Comments

  1. Great picture.
    The fortress and Mount Doom look great.
    I just love the way the smoke is billowing
    out, covering the sky.

    Comment by FrodoTook - July 23, 2001 @ 9:10 PM - Rated a 5

  2. Great picture.
    The fortress and Mount Doom look great.
    I just love the way the smoke is billowing
    out, covering the sky.

    Comment by FrodoTook - July 23, 2001 @ 9:10 PM - Rated a 5

  3. this is pretty close to my interpertation of this scene as well. It truly gives the impression that you are about to enter hell itself

    Comment by finrodfelegund - August 16, 2001 @ 1:12 PM - Rated a 4

  4. this is pretty close to my interpertation of this scene as well. It truly gives the impression that you are about to enter hell itself

    Comment by finrodfelegund - August 16, 2001 @ 1:12 PM - Rated a 4

  5. I'm not sure about Cirith Ungol, but Mount Doom looks great!

    Comment by drkirr - September 10, 2001 @ 8:52 PM - Rated a 4

  6. I'm not sure about Cirith Ungol, but Mount Doom looks great!

    Comment by drkirr - September 10, 2001 @ 8:52 PM - Rated a 4

  7. Just how i imagined it!

    Comment by samwise-gamgee - January 12, 2002 @ 7:05 PM - Rated a 5

  8. Just how i imagined it!

    Comment by samwise-gamgee - January 12, 2002 @ 7:05 PM - Rated a 5

  9. Comment by EowynEorling - January 5, 2003 @ 5:27 PM - Rated a 5

  10. Comment by EowynEorling - January 5, 2003 @ 5:27 PM - Rated a 5

  11. great pic

    Comment by bcorbett67 - January 7, 2003 @ 3:44 PM - Rated a 5

  12. great pic

    Comment by bcorbett67 - January 7, 2003 @ 3:44 PM - Rated a 5

  13. it i vey well drawn, still i think the place should be far creepier, the architecture far devilish, and the environmen faaaaaaaar darker, but it's very good anyway

    Comment by luindilien - January 7, 2003 @ 7:00 PM - Rated a 3

  14. it i vey well drawn, still i think the place should be far creepier, the architecture far devilish, and the environmen faaaaaaaar darker, but it's very good anyway

    Comment by luindilien - January 7, 2003 @ 7:00 PM - Rated a 3

  15. In comparison to Alan Lee's drab, boring, featureless, and all-around horrible depiction of Cirith Ungol, this KICKS BUTT! Perfect representation in my opinion.

    Comment by im2q4u - January 8, 2003 @ 1:17 AM - Rated a 5

  16. In comparison to Alan Lee's drab, boring, featureless, and all-around horrible depiction of Cirith Ungol, this KICKS BUTT! Perfect representation in my opinion.

    Comment by im2q4u - January 8, 2003 @ 1:17 AM - Rated a 5

  17. Like luindilien, I imagined that "the place should be far creepier, the architecture far devilish, and the environmen faaaaaaaar darker" but this is a wonderful depiction, even though the smoke from Mount Doom does look a bit stylized... but I guess the artist did that on purpose.

    Comment by Indolossė - January 8, 2003 @ 3:33 AM - Rated a 4

  18. Like luindilien, I imagined that "the place should be far creepier, the architecture far devilish, and the environmen faaaaaaaar darker" but this is a wonderful depiction, even though the smoke from Mount Doom does look a bit stylized... but I guess the artist did that on purpose.

    Comment by Indolossė - January 8, 2003 @ 3:33 AM - Rated a 4

  19. Great picture. better than most pictures i've seen on this web site.

    Comment by Feanors_Silmarils - February 8, 2003 @ 3:22 PM - Rated a 5

  20. Great picture. better than most pictures i've seen on this web site.

    Comment by Feanors_Silmarils - February 8, 2003 @ 3:22 PM - Rated a 5

  21. hehe, sam is so short

    hehe

    Comment by Legolasette - February 8, 2003 @ 7:02 PM - Rated a 4

  22. hehe, sam is so short

    hehe

    Comment by Legolasette - February 8, 2003 @ 7:02 PM - Rated a 4

  23. This picture is something else! I never have seen a picture as cool as this one. I know that this picture deserves a high points. So for this picture I give it 5 points. Good job and great work!

    Comment by kcamericanangel1 - February 26, 2003 @ 4:19 PM - Rated a 5

  24. This picture is something else! I never have seen a picture as cool as this one. I know that this picture deserves a high points. So for this picture I give it 5 points. Good job and great work!

    Comment by kcamericanangel1 - February 26, 2003 @ 4:19 PM - Rated a 5

  25. Super cool

    Comment by The_wizard - February 28, 2003 @ 6:18 AM

  26. Super cool

    Comment by The_wizard - February 28, 2003 @ 6:18 AM

  27. This picture is rated too low, IMO. Great to see soem originality... great use of color! Wow, I'm not sure what to say. I can't pick it apart too much, so obviously I like it One of my favorite non-movie peices of artwork I've seen on here... I wonder if I can get it to work as my wallpaper.

    Comment by Aniron_R - March 1, 2003 @ 10:46 AM - Rated a 5

  28. This picture is rated too low, IMO. Great to see soem originality... great use of color! Wow, I'm not sure what to say. I can't pick it apart too much, so obviously I like it One of my favorite non-movie peices of artwork I've seen on here... I wonder if I can get it to work as my wallpaper.

    Comment by Aniron_R - March 1, 2003 @ 10:46 AM - Rated a 5

  29. I especially like the detail of Orodruin in the back... the red billowy clouds of doom are great!

    Comment by LightOfLaurelin - March 2, 2003 @ 3:31 PM - Rated a 5

  30. I especially like the detail of Orodruin in the back... the red billowy clouds of doom are great!

    Comment by LightOfLaurelin - March 2, 2003 @ 3:31 PM - Rated a 5

  31. WWWWWWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOWWWWQ..Dbloody amaazing!!!!!! i love it! sam looks so cute..where is frodo? oh well, looks great anyway...THAT is hereby the background on my computer someone! buy the artist a pint!

    Comment by $mAug_dRagYn - March 2, 2003 @ 11:35 PM - Rated a 5

  32. WWWWWWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOWWWWQ..Dbloody amaazing!!!!!! i love it! sam looks so cute..where is frodo? oh well, looks great anyway...THAT is hereby the background on my computer someone! buy the artist a pint!

    Comment by $mAug_dRagYn - March 2, 2003 @ 11:35 PM - Rated a 5

  33. Frodos not there... sam thinks hes dead

    Comment by Gromnick - March 3, 2003 @ 5:36 AM

  34. Frodos not there... sam thinks hes dead

    Comment by Gromnick - March 3, 2003 @ 5:36 AM

  35. i think this picture is from a 1970s hilderbrant (spelling?) calender that i had when i was a kid. does anyone know if this is possible? still looks great, almost 30 years later!

    Comment by dragongirl - March 3, 2003 @ 6:34 AM

  36. i think this picture is from a 1970s hilderbrant (spelling?) calender that i had when i was a kid. does anyone know if this is possible? still looks great, almost 30 years later!

    Comment by dragongirl - March 3, 2003 @ 6:34 AM

  37. It does look like it's from the '70s. This also reminds me of that Isengard painting that I recently rated. It looks like it's from a fairy-tale story. Oh well. I'll give a couple points for it's detail...and it's not the worst I have seen.

    Comment by LOTRfreak02 - March 3, 2003 @ 10:22 AM - Rated a 3

  38. It does look like it's from the '70s. This also reminds me of that Isengard painting that I recently rated. It looks like it's from a fairy-tale story. Oh well. I'll give a couple points for it's detail...and it's not the worst I have seen.

    Comment by LOTRfreak02 - March 3, 2003 @ 10:22 AM - Rated a 3

  39. I think it is ok but it should look a lot scarier
    more heckish you know but otherwise it was a good conception of Cirith Ungol

    Comment by THE.GOBLIN.KILLER - March 6, 2003 @ 9:16 AM - Rated a 2

  40. I think it is ok but it should look a lot scarier
    more heckish you know but otherwise it was a good conception of Cirith Ungol

    Comment by THE.GOBLIN.KILLER - March 6, 2003 @ 9:16 AM - Rated a 2

  41. i like it

    Comment by ilikesamalot - May 2, 2003 @ 6:25 PM - Rated a 5

  42. i like it

    Comment by ilikesamalot - May 2, 2003 @ 6:25 PM - Rated a 5

  43. No mistakes about the beauty of this piece of art, if I can say that. Great, it gives me an unpleasant feeling. That means: good!

    Comment by Elfje - June 6, 2003 @ 9:17 AM - Rated a 5

  44. No mistakes about the beauty of this piece of art, if I can say that. Great, it gives me an unpleasant feeling. That means: good!

    Comment by Elfje - June 6, 2003 @ 9:17 AM - Rated a 5

  45. awesome!

    Comment by The-Witch-King-of-Agmar - June 28, 2004 @ 1:52 PM - Rated a 5

  46. Wow Man, check it out!

    Comment by Daelgath - February 13, 2005 @ 6:59 PM - Rated a 4

Leave a Comment

Close This Window

Goto The One Ring Home Page